Listing
Herein I create a handy little listing, sorted by ranking, of our local pizzerias. This is the fucking gospel. I am infallible and this shit is indeed for real. Myrrh can fuck right off, oregano is my jam. This shit's for your convenience so fuck you.
Top Tier
Brooklyn (Ogden) (1)
I <3 NY Pizza (1.5)
Terrazzo Trattoria (1.5)
Nicola's (2)
Falcone's Italian Restaurant (2)
Brooklyn (Hampstead) (2)
Pizzetta's (2 - formerly 4.5)
Uncle Vinny's Italian Ristorante (2)
Reel Pizza (2.5)
Michaelangelo's (Carolina Beach) (2.5)
Tony's (2.5) CLOSED
Nino's (3) CHANGED OWNERS
Brixx (3)
Vito's Pizzeria (3)
Incredible Pizza (New Centre) (3)
Spicoli (3)
Slice of Life (Mall)
Siena (3.5)
In-n-Out Pizza & Subs (3.5)
Amore Pizza & Pasta (Wrightsboro) (3.5)
Mid Tier
Pepperoni Grill (4)
Mellow Mushroom (Wrightsville) (4)
Michaelangelo's (UNCW) (4)
Amore on Market (4)
Hungry Heroes (4)
Fat Tony's (Downtown) (4)
Uncle Louie's Pizza Lounge (4.5)
Tower Pizza (4.5) CLOSED
Bessie & Giuseppe (4.5) CLOSED
Scotto Pizza (4.5) CLOSED
Luciano's (5) CLOSED
Mellow Mushroom (Oleander) (5)
Brooklyn Sal's Famous Pizza (5) CLOSED
Avanti (5) CLOSED
Hoobie's (5)
Marco's Pizza (5)
Nino's (Eastwood/Market) (5) CLOSED
Frank's (5.5)
Wilmington's House of Pizza (5.5)
Slice of Life (Downtown) (5.5)
Slice of Life (Military Cutoff) (5.5)
Papa Bella's (5.5) CLOSED
Subway (Monkey Junction) (5.5)
Fishy
KickBack Jack's (6)
Gumby's (6) CLOSED
Incredible (Eastwood) (6)
Krazy (6)
CiCi's Pizza (6)
Times Square Pizza (6) CLOSED
Goodfellas (6.5) CLOSED
Whole Foods (6.5)
Incredible (South College) (6.5)
Elizabeth's (6.5)
Michaelangelo's (Monkey Junction) (6.5)
Antonio's (Porters Neck) (6.5)
Fucked
Harris Teeter (Oleander) (7)
Antonio's (MJ) (7)
Princess Pizza (7) CLOSED
Slice of Life (Pine Valley) (7.5)
Hibachi Grill & Supreme Buffet (7.5)
Papa Murphy's (7.5)
Sbarro (8) CLOSED
Costco (8 - Infinite Recirc)
March 17th, 2012 - 04:20
check out Pizzeta’s on Oleander. I’m curious how it ranks.
March 19th, 2012 - 08:01
It’s up there at 4.5. I plan on going back because I like the rest of their food and may have eaten the pizza on an off day.